Dr K Atkinson's lectures for Geog 1020, Geography of Natural Resources.

 Contents

Introduction

Abbreviations.

The Lectures

  1. Physical and Economic Aspects of Agriculture.
  2. Environmentally Friendly Agriculture
  3. Woodland in the UK Landscape
  4. Twentieth-century Afforestation
  5. National and Country parks
  6. Aims of nature conservation in the UK
  7. Planning and Management of nature reserves
  8. Urban and Industrial Conservation

 

Introduction.

These are the bare bones of the lecture notes. They are not a substitute for attendance, reading or unfetterred and wanton debauchery. They are not even reliable, so if you spot a mistake, wish to add something, or have good links, please send me them.

They are here because I got a miserable "F" in Dr Grainger's Exam, and if they can help me or anybody else, good.

Abbreviations. Not a comprehensive list (obviously) Can you fill in the gaps?

CC

Countryside commission

NPA

National Park Authority

CGT

Capital Gains Tax

NT

National Trust

CLA

Country Landowners Association

NVZ

Nitrate Vulnerable Zone

CPRE

Council for the Protection of Rural England

PET

Potential Evapo-transpiratiom

DOE

Department of the Environment

PSMD

Potential Soil Moisture Deficit

EN

English Nature (formerly Nature Conservancy Council)

PT

Potential Transpiration

ESA

Environmentally sensitive Area

RA

Ramblers Association

FC

Forestry Commission

RSNC

Royal Society for Nature Conservation

FLD

Friends of the Lake District

RSPB

Royal Society for the protection of Birds

FWAG

Farming Wildlife and Advisory Group

SPNR

Society for the Promotion of Nature Reserves

IUCN

International Council for the Conservation of Nature

SSSI

Site of special scientific interest

LDSPB

Lake District Special Planning Board (the NPA for the

UNCLE

United Network Command for Law and Enforcement

LFA

Less Favoured Area

WA

Water Authority

MAFF

Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food


Lecture 1: 8.11.00. Physical and Economic Aspects of Agriculture.

There is considerable and varied interplay between

To a degree symbiosis and conflict occurs between all these agencies. These lectures will explore that relationship.

Nomenclature.

Yield = Yg = f(ErEtSwSnM)

I.e. The yield of a genotype is a function of

E t, in reference to yield is expressed as an accumulated temperature above one of three preordained values. If we imagine a sample of temperatures expressed as a stem and leaf plot, Et is the sum of the leaves, the stem being 0°, 6° or 10° C.

Accumulated temperature is a function of

Potential Transpiration (PT) or Potential Evapotranspiration (PET).

PT - P = PSMD (Potential Soil Moisture Deficit).

Field Capacity Days

In this context Capacity is the amount of water a field holds if free drainage is allowed.

N.B. It might not be easy to work soil at full capacity.

LFAs (Less Favoured Areas)

Are areas that get help, e.g. Hill Livestock in the form of compensatory allowances.

Its aims are to maintain

Economic margins in Agriculture.

GM = O - VC

Gross Margins = Output - Variable Costs

NFI = GM - FC

Net Farm Income = Gross margins - Fixed Costs

Variable Costs might include

Fixed Costs might include

The BIG variable in all these equations is PRICE


Lecture 2: 13.11.00. Environmentally Friendly Agriculture - Three Topics

  1. Impacts on Landscape Quality and Wildlife.

The last century can be divided into the following periods of Agriculture/Environment approaches.

1900-47 Conservatism and compatibility. There was no real pressure outside the world wars to increase yield or intensify. Cheap imports meant that the home yield was less important.

1947-81 Concern and Conflict. Government intervention on prices led to intensification, resulting in degradation in the biodiversity of the countryside and the quality of the agro-environment.

1981-2000 Partial reconciliation. The Wildlife & Countryside act of 1981 was an indicator of the concerns of 'environmentalists' being addressed.

The concerns include: -

  1. Environmental Farming.

Organisations.

MAFF; The Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food ostensibly deals with environmental farming. Environmental initiatives include

FWAGs; Farming and Wildlife Advisory Groups. Set up initially in 1970 these were groups of locally based farmers, often based in a county town.

ESA's (Environmentally sensitive areas). (MAFF managed) There are currently 38 for example the Lake District and The Pennine Dales.

An ESA is.

The example we saw, the Dales, was threatened by.

The Mechanisms vary between local ESA's; nevertheless the Pennine Dales is not untypical in that

The prescriptions are broadly.

The payments are.

  1. NVZs (Nitrate Vulnerable Zones).

In these areas farms are obliged to keep a field by field record of organic and inorganic use. They are MANDATORY. They are where

Both Organic and inorganic applications are illegal under these circumstances.

MAFF Agro/environmental schemes are

Countryside Stewardship Scheme - preserving unusual habitat for rare species

Environmentally Sensitive Areas Scheme

Energy Crops Scheme

Farm Woodland Premium Scheme

Hill Farm Allowance Scheme

Organic Farming Scheme

Processing and Marketing Grant

Rural Enterprise Scheme

Vocational Training

Woodland Grant Scheme

Pre-ERDP Schemes

Many schemes to promote a harmonic relationship between agriculture and the countryside fall under the remit of the DOE (Department of the Environment).


Lecture 3. 13.11.00 Woodland in the UK Landscape

  1. The Holocene Evolution.

We can tell from roots and pollen remains that Britain was populated by Trees.

C.4,500 BC there was 95% cover comprising

2 Management

From 1000 to 1500 Laws were passed to

Protect the Vert (Flora)

Protect the Venison (Fauna, particularly the game)

Along with rights and charters encompassing

'Pollarding' and 'Coppicing' were (are) ways of management.


 Lecture 4: 20.11.00 Afforestation in the 20th Century

  1. Policy

We know that the nadir of the UK forest was around the end of the Great War, when only 5% of the island was wooded.

1919 Forestry act addressed this decline

1945 Forestry Act likewise.

It became strategically important to achieve a degree of self- sufficiency in wood. Cheap imports created a dependency, especially in times of crisis.

  1. The treasury made a 'Forestry Cost-benefit study'.
  1. Budget changes.

Cost Benefit analysis is particularly relevant to forestry, as a long time elapses before any financial gains are returned from planting. Even then returns are relatively low compared with other investments (In the region of 3%)

The following sum is used in calculating the worth of forestry.

(Where C = Costs, B = Benefits, n = years and i= interest rates

(This means that low interest rates favour forestry)

Policy Budget 1988

  1. Promote planting, especially Scottish & Welsh upland, English Lowland
  2. Schedule B & Schedule D Fiscal allowances abolished
  3. Increased planting grants:-
  1. Cost allowances on Capital Gains Tax.
  2. Target plant of 33,000 hectares per annum. (This seems, retrospectively, optimistic)
  1. MANAGEMENT

There has been a tradition of introduction of forest species to the UK, one of the Earliest being the Douglas Fir in the 16th century and later, The Larch.

The productivity of successful introduced species can be much higher, e.g.

NB Forestry is a more Intensive employer than much other agriculture.

  1. Environmental Problems
  1. Windthrow and Fire
  2. Competition and Disease
  3. Biodiversity
  4. Water Quality
  5. Landscape
  1. "Green" Policy in the 1990’s

Forests provide other things apart from a mere 3% return

Aesthetics, e.g. Lowland Landscape design guidelines are in place.

Wildlife conservation, e.g. there are 300+ forest SSSIs

Recreation, e.g. Forests for people, e.g. National Forest and Community Forest


Lecture 5: 27.11.00 National and Country Parks

A National Park is defined by IUCN Cat II National Parks

  1. Extensive natural area
  2. Protected from exploitation
  3. Responsibility of Government
  4. Land owned publicly
  5. Protected from occupation

Cat V Protected landscape

  1. Outstanding (semi) natural landscape
  2. In productive use
  3. Responsibility of local government
  4. Land mainly privately owned
  5. Inhabited

Policy (in the UK) has been set in and by

  1. Scott
  1. Dower
  2. Hobhouse
  1. National Parks and access to countryside act
  1. Ten Parks designated
  1. Countryside act
  1. Local government Act
  2. Sandford (review)
  1. Local Authority special department orders
  1. Broads designated
  2. Edwards 'Fit for the future'
  1. Reorganisation of the countryside office
  1. Environment Act

National Park Administration

Section 61 of the 1995 act gives the purpose of National Parks as

  1. Conserving and enhancing the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage.
  1. Pursuing…the understanding and enjoyment… of these areas by the public.

And cites mechanism

'The authority shall seek to foster the economic and social well-being of local communities…but without incurring significant expenditure' and 'co-operate with local bodies whose functions include the promotion of social and economic development'

 E.G. The Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority

Has about 100 staff with a budget for an income of c £3 million per annum, received from schemes such as Environmentally sensitive Areas etc. The organisation is set out

National Park Officer

Park Management

Planning and administration

Landscape Conservation

Area management

Access and Recreation

Information Services

Policy and Built Environment

Support services

Development control

'So many demands made by so many self-interested people'

Lake District planning problems

Consumptive v Conservation

  • MAFF
  • NFU
  • FC
  • WA
  • CLA
  • LDSPB
  • NPA
  • CC
  • RA
  • NT
  • EN
  • FLD
  • CPRE
  • Main management problems

    Landscape preservation - Afforestation is the biggest problem.

    1. CPRE and FC struck a gentlemen's agreement
    1. Upland management experiment
    1. Upland management service
    1. Moorland map - had to be produced. Heather moorland has value as a habitat.

    Quarter of the Lake District is NT (57,000 ha, 200 Houses, 86 Farms, 4,000 ha woodland, 25,000 Sheep)

    Recreation.

    'Of all noxious animals, the most noxious is the tourist'

    For visitors, the lakes are divided into

    Honeypot Areas

    Toleration Areas

    Quiet Areas.

    Access - Country Parks. Countryside act of 1968 states 'A park or pleasure ground for the purposes of providing, or improving opportunities for the enjoyment of the countryside by the public


    Lecture 6: 27.11.00 Aims of Nature Conservation in the UK

    Motives for wildlife conservation

    1820 - 1890 Humanitarian

    1870 - 1940 Preservationist

    1910 - 1970 Scientific

    1970 - Now Popular

    Voluntary bodies for nature conservation include (Amongst many)

    1. RSPB
    1. NT (For historic buildings and AONB)
    1. CPRE
    1. Wildfowl and Wetlands trust
    1. Woodland trust

    E.g. NT membership has rocketed

    In 1912 the SPNR was founded, changed to the RSNC in 1982 and the wildlife Trust in 1994. The WT are county-based trusts, with the local trusts having total ownership. The trust is inviolate. There are 47 separate naturalist trusts.

    Designated areas for wildlife conservation in GB

    Body

    Number

    Area ('000 ha)

    % GB

    RSPB

    121

    70

     

    W.T's

    2200

    70

     

    NNR's

    234

    166

    0× 8

    SSSI's

    5184

    1641

    7.9

    LNR's

    78

    12

     


    Lecture 7: 4.12.00. Planning and Management of Nature reserves

    1. Voluntary conservation movement
    2. State legislature for Nature conservation
    3. 1947 Huxley Sub-committee

      1949 National Parks and access to countryside act. Set up NNNR's and SSSI's (since there has been a steady rise in NNR's

    4. 1977 Nature conservancy review was instigated. (Derek Ratcliffe drew up an extended 'Hit List' of sites) culminating in NCR, a list of c. 750 sites identified to be NNR's. Half sites were woodland, the other half having an even distribution of Coast, Wetlands, Heath and Upland grassland.

    The NCR list considered

    Primary Criteria

    Subsidiary Criteria

    Special Considerations

    • Size
    • Diversity
    • Naturalness
    • Typicalness
  • Recorded history
  • Position in Geographical unit
  • Potential Value
  • Intrinsic Appeal
  • Rarity
  • Fragility
  • N.B. attempts at Marine Nature Reserves (MNR's ) were established at

    But were converted to voluntary reserves.

    International agreements for nature conservation.

    1. Ramsar convention on Wetlands of international importance, especially of Waterfowl habitat (UX1976)(96 sites)
    1. Bird Directive from the EU on the conservation of wild birds, naming 77 Special Protection Area's (SPA's)
    1. Bern Convention. Conservation of European wildlife and habitats

    1992 Habitats and species directives on the Bern Convention

    Management of Nature reserves

    Protection of SSSI's - Quite a few designated by other bodies, - RSPB WT's etc. In 1981 SSSI's were not given full protection. Agreements may be hammered out, normally successful.

    Constraints on management

    1 Finance - English Nature may help, but some small organisations struggle.

    INCA - Industrial Nature Conservation Associations

    2 Ownership - All voluntary sites are OK, but state sector is only 28% owned publicly, e.g. Cross Fell, Cwm Idwal

    3 Size - Average WT is 30 Hectares, Average National is 700 hectares.

    E.g. Esthwaite is so small its environs affect it greatly in character and chemistry

    4 Threats to ecological aims and objectives

    Management plans are now often in place (These help with governance and funding), but the best-laid plans..

    Threats are many and varied

    E.g. Rickarton Muir lowland heath wet acid grassland. In 1970 the gas pipeline was laid.

    Most threats are natural. A site's raison d'être may be compromised by invasion of other species.


      Lecture 8: 11.12.00 Read Selman Ch 6 (This has got to be a test)